8. Give details from the story to show how the years in prison had had a terrible effect on Dr Manette.
9. His cold white head mingled with her radiant yellow hair, which warmed and lighted it as though it were the light of Freedom shining on him. Do you think these lines convey a sense of hope or despair? Give a reason to support your answer.
10. Extended writing: What are the duties that a child has towards his or her parents? Do you think Lucie fulfils these duties?
Share
Answer:
8. The years of imprisonment had a terrible effect on Dr. Manette, which is evident in several ways throughout the story. When he is first released, he is in a state of severe mental and emotional distress. He has lost his sense of time and identity, and he mindlessly makes shoes, as that was the trade he practiced in prison. He is haunted by traumatic memories of his confinement, and he occasionally relapses into a state of shock and incoherence. He is deeply scarred by his past, and it takes time, care, and the support of his daughter Lucie to help him recover his mental and emotional well-being.
9. The lines "His cold white head mingled with her radiant yellow hair, which warmed and lighted it as though it were the light of Freedom shining on him" convey a sense of hope. The description of Lucie's radiant yellow hair warming and lighting Dr. Manette's head suggests that her presence and love bring warmth and light into his life. It symbolizes the hope and healing that she represents for him. Lucie is like a beacon of hope and freedom for Dr. Manette, who has suffered greatly in the past. Her presence brings comfort and a sense of renewal to his life.
10. The duties that a child has towards his or her parents can vary across cultures and personal beliefs, but they often include providing love, respect, care, and support. Lucie fulfills these duties remarkably well in the story. She is unwavering in her love and care for her father, Dr. Manette, even when he is in a fragile mental state. She offers him the emotional support he needs to recover from his traumatic past. Lucie's dedication to her father and her commitment to his well-being demonstrate her fulfillment of these duties. Additionally, she also supports her husband, Charles Darnay, and their daughter, embodying the role of a caring and devoted parent herself.
Verified answer
Explanation:
8. In the story, it is evident that the years spent in prison had a terrible effect on Dr. Manette. Here are some details that highlight this:
- Dr. Manette's mental and emotional state: He is depicted as a broken man, suffering from severe trauma and mental instability due to his unjust imprisonment. He experiences frequent relapses into a state of deep despair and depression.
- His physical condition: Dr. Manette's physical health deteriorates during his time in prison. He becomes weak, frail, and emaciated, showing signs of malnutrition and neglect.
- Obsession with shoemaking: As a coping mechanism, Dr. Manette develops an obsessive habit of making shoes. This behavior is a result of the trauma he endured in prison and serves as a way for him to find solace and distract himself from his painful memories.
9. These lines convey a sense of hope rather than despair. The description of Dr. Manette's cold white head mingling with Lucie's radiant yellow hair symbolizes the contrast between his past suffering and her presence as a source of warmth and light. The mention of "the light of Freedom shining on him" suggests that Lucie's love and support bring a sense of liberation and hope to Dr. Manette's life. Therefore, these lines evoke a feeling of hope and renewal.
10. The duties that a child has towards his or her parents can vary based on cultural and personal beliefs. However, some common duties include:
- Respect and obedience: Children are expected to show respect towards their parents and obey their reasonable requests and guidance.
- Care and support: Children should provide emotional and physical care to their parents, especially in their old age or times of need.
- Gratitude and appreciation: Expressing gratitude and appreciation for the love, sacrifices, and efforts made by parents is an important duty.
- Honoring their wishes: Children should consider their parents' wishes and values when making important life decisions.
Regarding Lucie fulfilling these duties, she can be seen as fulfilling them to a great extent. Throughout the story, Lucie shows immense love, care, and support for her father, Dr. Manette. She stands by him during his difficult times, helps him recover from his trauma, and provides him with a loving and nurturing environment. Lucie's unwavering dedication and selflessness towards her father demonstrate her fulfillment of the duties a child has towards their parents.